Showing posts with label FBI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FBI. Show all posts

Thursday, October 10, 2013

FBI Shuts Down Digital Black Market “Silk Road,” Seize Millions of Bitcoins



On October 2, 2013 the FBI arrested the alleged owner and operator of an illicit website that facilitated the sale of drugs, stolen bank information, hacking tools, firearms, and countless other illegal products and services.  The website, known as “Silk Road,” functioned as a black-market eBay, connecting buyers and suppliers through a seemingly untraceable underground website.  Before it was seized and shut down by the United States government, Silk Road was a massive criminal enterprise that generated $1.2 billion in sales over the course of only two years.  The site enabled several thousand drug dealers and other criminal vendors from over ten countries to conduct transactions anonymously over the Internet.  The alleged mastermind of Silk Road is 29-year old Ross Ulbricht, a former physicist who went by the username “Dread Pirate Roberts,” a reference to the movie, “The Princess Bride.”  Ulbricht made approximately $88 million by charging a commission for every transaction conducted on Silk Road.  As owner and operator of Silk Road, Ulbricht is accused by U.S. Attorneys of narcotics trafficking conspiracy, computer hacking conspiracy, and money laundering conspiracy.  It is also believed that Ulbricht had hired a hitman to execute two people, one a former employee, and the other, a man attempting to blackmail Ulbricht.

Silk Road operated on the “Deep Web,” an area that cannot be found using standard search engines like Google or Yahoo.  Silk Road operated on the “Tor” network, (a.k.a “The Onion Network”) a special network on the Internet designed to mask users’ IP addresses, making it nearly impossible to physically locate the computers hosting or accessing websites on the network.  To access the site, a user would first download the necessary Tor browser software, usually available for free.  From there a user would simply type in the Silk Road’s “.onion” address into their newly downloaded Tor browser.  However, one could not simply stumble upon Silk Road while using a search engine, even if they were using Tor browser software.  The actual Silk Road’s domain name had to be discovered, either through word-of-mouth or by searching Internet forums and chatrooms.

To further ensure anonymity, the only currency permitted on Silk Road was Bitcoins, a new form of virtual currency.  It is an anonymous, decentralized form of electronic currency, not backed by any government or bank.  The currency does not have any tangible form and instead exists only on the Internet.  Bitcoins are legal and can typically be purchased from Bitcoin exchanges, such as www.Mtgox.com.  These exchanges also allow users to exchange their Bitcoins for conventional currency, which is valued based on a fluctuating exchange rate. The number of Bitcoins in existence is limited, however, at 21 million (though only 11.7 million are currently in circulation), to protect its value from inflation.  Each individual Bitcoin is represented by a unique online registration number, 64 digits long.  To receive a Bitcoin a user must also have a Bitcoin address, a randomly generated string of 27-34 numbers and letters.  This address acts as a virtual mailbox to and from which Bitcoins are delivered.  There is no registry of these virtual Bitcoin mailboxes, which allows users to remain anonymous.  However, all Bitcoin transactions are recorded to a public ledger known as the “Blockchain,” although the ledger only illustrates the movement of funds between anonymous Bitcoin addresses.  This prevents a user from spending the same Bitcoin more than once.

As this investigation proves, however, maintaining anonymity on the Web, even the Deep Web, is no easy task.  The FBI was able to trace and finally arrest Ulbricht by scouring Internet forums.  After identifying the first ever mention of Silk Road in a forum, the Feds proceeded on a hunch that this initial post originated from or would lead to Silk Road’s founder.  The FBI was correct in its assertion and was able to uncover and track countless communications from Ulbricht regarding his operation of this digital black market.  This investigation also demonstrates that Bitcoins are not untouchable.  The FBI has thus far seized Bitcoins from Silk Road worth approximately $3.6 million as a result of this investigation.  In turn, the value of the Bitcoin dropped about 20% when the news of Silk Road’s shutdown was first announced, October 2, 2013.  It has since clambered back in value, though not to its previous levels.
 
The entire copy of the Federal complaint against Ross Ulbricht and Silk Road can be found here.

(Blog entry written by Alex Diamond, IBLT/Carter DeLuca Entrepreneurship Support Fellow for the Fall 2013 semester)

Thursday, September 20, 2012

The Havoc of a Device Identifier – Apple UDIDs

Most users of the iPhone are completely unaware that Apple has assigned their individual devices a Unique Device Identifier (UDID).  While such an identifier contains numerous privacy implications, it was not until recently that the general public became acutely aware of these UDIDs.  In a post on Pastebin, on September 4, 2012, the hacker group AntiSec announced that they had obtained a file containing over twelve million Apple UDIDs from a FBI laptop.  While the FBI quickly denied this, stating that the laptop was not hacked and that the FBI did not hold such a file, this event led to several articles by numerous tech and law blogs diving into the topic of UDIDs and what these identifiers actually means for iPod Touch, iPhone and iPad users. (In addition, it is possible that non-Apple devices also contain a similar identifier to the UDID and the public has not been made aware of this yet.)
   
One such article, featured on The Verge, focused on what one is capable of doing when they obtain a user’s UDID.  It should be noted before delving into the various privacy problems that results from UDIDs existing that Apple has announced that UDIDs will be replaced by “a new set of APIs” in iOS 6 (released on 9/19/2012), the newest operating system for iPhone and the iPad.  However, it is unclear just what sort of information these new APIs will contain.  The writer of The Verge article, Joshua Kopstein, points out that it is unclear what exactly someone could do with a UDID and industry experts disagree as to the extent of harm that can come solely from a UDID: 

In a recent article posted on CNET, Frank Heidt, chief executive of Leviathan Security claimed that with a UDID, a push token, and a device name, an attacker "could arbitrarily load an app on your phone." But Alex Radocea, a senior engineer at CrowdStrike, says that’s not true.

"There’s been a lot of misinformation," Radocea told The Verge over the phone. Just as AntiSec released their list of device IDs, he and his team posted the results of their examination of the iOS version of FinSpy Mobile, a strain of the infamous FinFisher spyware that was recently found targeting political dissidents.

In their report, CrowdStrike points out that the spyware is using ad-hoc distribution, a method usually reserved for testing which uses UDIDs to bypass Apple’s application signing process. But that doesn’t mean that a UDID is the magic bullet for remotely installing malware on a device without the user’s knowledge, Radocea says.

"The main thing is that user interaction is required to install these applications," he clarified. "They cannot be silently or arbitrarily installed, as the CNET article alleges." In a blog post written shortly after news hit of AntiSec’s release, the ACLU similarly suggested that UDIDs could be used to secretly infect devices with the spyware.

Kopstein goes on to further discuss how in the past UDIDs have been used to access the geographic information of an individual user.  In addition, the UDID is solely in the control of Apple, and the only way for an individual to get a new UDID is to get a new iPod Touch, iPhone or iPad. 

What exactly the release of these 12 million UDID truly means is still unclear, but if nothing else, this release has raised public awareness of the issue.  (There is also a large concern over whether or not the FBI actually had these 12 million UDIDs, what the FBI was doing with this data, and if they truly did have the file, why was it being stored on a laptop that was so easily hacked?) And, as discussed earlier, Apple is removing the UDID from the newest version of its operating system.  However, the fact remains that millions of iPod Touches, iPhones and iPads contain a unique identifier over which the user has no control and which can do uncertain things to a user’s personal device

Via The Verge
(Written by Brett Alazraki, Fall 2012 IBLT Entrepreneurship Assistance Fellow)